Does Range Filter beat buy and hold on Bitcoin?

    With its default settings, daily candles and 0.1% fees, Range Filter on Bitcoin returned 31.6% a year since 2018 in our simulated backtest, with a worst drop of 55.6%. Its MAR (yearly return divided by the worst drop) is 0.57, against 0.24 for simply holding Bitcoin: it beat buy and hold. It ranks 11 of 26 indicators we tested on Bitcoin. Its success rate (win rate) was 43% across 49 trades.

    How Range Filter would have traded Bitcoin on daily candles, under the same rules we use for our own strategies, side by side with our Bitcoin strategy and with simply holding Bitcoin.

    Simulated backtest · not real performance · not investment advice.

    Asset

    Timeframe

    The rule we test

    Long on the Range Filter buy signal (sampling period 100, multiplier 3); cash on its sell signal.

    Range Filter by DonovanWall, buy/sell version by guikroth: https://www.tradingview.com/script/J8GzFGfD-Range-Filter-Buy-and-Sell-5min-guikroth-version/

    Same conditions for everyone

    Long only, 100% of equity, 0.1% commission per side, no slippage, fills at next open, default settings, trading from 2018-01-01.

    Today: in cash since Oct 29, 2026

    Decision bar: Nov 17, 2026 · valid until 2026-11-19T00:45:00Z · JSON for your bot

    Simulated backtest, not real performance. Not investment advice.

    Jan 1, 2023 to Nov 17, 2026 · Simulated backtest · not real performance · not investment advice. Each row uses its published window dates.

    SuperTrend+103.8%+20.2%−46.0%0.440.721850%56%
    Ichimoku+116.6%+22.1%−34.6%0.640.761443%59%
    MoneyLine+132.1%+24.3%−35.6%0.680.811644%59%
    UT Bot Alerts+156.3%+27.5%−30.8%0.890.917637%53%
    Chandelier Exit+220.6%+35.1%−40.5%0.861.071947%59%
    HalfTrend+105.5%+20.4%−37.9%0.540.743349%53%
    Range Filter+116.3%+22.0%−44.8%0.490.762446%56%
    Gaussian Channel+265.5%+39.7%−28.6%1.391.243132%45%
    Pivot Point SuperTrend+114.8%+21.8%−45.7%0.480.741250%63%
    AlphaTrend+166.5%+28.8%−37.0%0.780.911844%60%
    Hull Suite+262.3%+39.4%−33.8%1.171.193247%52%
    ML Adaptive SuperTrend+55.3%+12.0%−52.7%0.230.512040%54%
    Zero Lag Trend Signals+217.1%+34.7%−38.7%0.901.131759%51%
    Zero-Lag MA Trend Levels+398.3%+51.3%−26.2%1.961.392446%56%
    Golden Cross (50/200)+53.9%+11.8%−48.7%0.240.48475%64%
    200-Day Moving Average+201.2%+32.9%−31.7%1.040.941735%66%
    MACD (12, 26, 9)+152.6%+27.0%−34.6%0.780.945338%48%
    RSI 14 above 50+230.9%+36.2%−39.4%0.921.086926%56%
    Donchian Breakout (Turtle 20/10)+131.4%+24.2%−38.0%0.640.862246%49%
    Parabolic SAR+65.8%+13.9%−36.6%0.380.576237%53%
    Squeeze Momentum+140.9%+25.5%−39.6%0.640.843642%54%
    Volumatic VIDYA+57.6%+12.4%−43.2%0.290.511258%59%
    Volumatic Trend+305.1%+43.5%−29.5%1.471.233631%57%
    Strategya.pro LineRegister →+284.1%+41.5%−24.2%1.721.19771%56%
    Strategya.pro Trend EngineRegister →+507.7%+59.3%−17.5%3.381.701182%41%
    Strategya.pro ATR LineRegister →+232.3%+36.3%−29.4%1.231.094846%54%
    Strategya.pro BTC 1D7 days free →+576.3%+63.7%−17.5%3.651.901471%—
    Holding BTC+290.9%+42.1%−53.0%0.800.99———

    BTC price and growth of $1,000

    Simulated backtest · not real performance · not investment advice. Rebased at the window start; missing history is not estimated.

    Paid strategy curve · delayed 30 days · data before 2026-10-18. Benchmark and holding curves are not delayed.

    Loading published charts…
    Range FilterStrategya.pro BTC 1DHolding BTC

    Read this before comparing

    The indicators run with their default settings. Our paid strategies were calibrated on data that includes these same years, so the comparison favors them. Strategya.pro Line and Trend Engine were also designed on Bitcoin. Strategya.pro ATR Line was also set looking at this same history. The fair test is what happens from now on: every row keeps updating. All figures are simulated backtests, not real performance. Not investment advice.

    Want today's signal, not just the backtest?

    See where our BTC 1D strategy stands today and every day.

    Try 7 days free · no card

    What is Range Filter?

    Range Filter smooths price with an average of its recent ranges and only moves when price leaves that band, so sideways noise is ignored. Original by DonovanWall; the buy and sell version is by guikroth.

    Range Filter by DonovanWall, buy/sell version by guikroth: https://www.tradingview.com/script/J8GzFGfD-Range-Filter-Buy-and-Sell-5min-guikroth-version/

    Questions

    Does Range Filter work on Bitcoin?

    Over the full history its MAR (CAGR divided by max drawdown) is 0.57, against 0.24 for holding Bitcoin. It ranks 11 of 26 indicators tested on Bitcoin. Check each window above: one good period can hide a weak one. Simulated backtest, not real performance. Not investment advice.

    Why compare with holding?

    Holding is the simplest alternative. A rule is only worth following if it improves return, drawdown, or both.

    Can I automate it?

    Yes. Each benchmark publishes today's position (in or out, and since when) as a free JSON file you can connect to your own bot. Benchmarks are free indicators, not paid strategy signals.

    What is the success rate of the Range Filter strategy on Bitcoin?

    Since 2018, 49 trades closed and 43% of them were winners. That share is the win rate, also called the success rate. Trend rules often win fewer than half of their trades and still come out ahead, because a few long winners pay for many small losses, so read it together with the yearly return and the worst drop. Simulated backtest, not real performance.

    Compare all 26 indicators on 3 assets

    67 of 78 indicator-asset pairs beat holding on risk-adjusted return (MAR) over the full history · 75 of 78 are in cash today.

    IndicatorBitcoinEthereumSolana
    Holding0.240.110.67
    Ours · calibrated on these years
    Strategya.pro LineFREE0.83today: free account0.80today: free account0.06today: free account
    Strategya.pro Trend EngineFREE2.13today: free account1.09today: free account-0.22today: free account
    Strategya.pro ATR LineFREE0.43today: free account0.49today: free account1.61today: free account
    Popular indicators
    SuperTrend0.42cash · Oct 290.84cash · Oct 81.94cash · Oct 12
    Ichimoku0.67cash · Nov 50.40cash · Oct 251.44cash · Oct 29
    MoneyLine0.51cash · Oct 291.12cash · Oct 81.83cash · Oct 8
    UT Bot Alerts0.34cash · Nov 50.39cash · Nov 51.12cash · Oct 7
    Chandelier Exit0.46cash · Oct 251.00cash · Oct 82.64cash · Oct 12
    HalfTrend0.19cash · Oct 80.29cash · Oct 80.92cash · Oct 8
    Range Filter0.57cash · Oct 290.29cash · Oct 80.41cash · Oct 12
    Gaussian Channel1.37cash · Oct 220.38cash · Oct 121.70cash · Oct 12
    Pivot Point SuperTrend0.67cash · Oct 290.33cash · Oct 120.75cash · Oct 14
    AlphaTrend0.83cash · Oct 260.79cash · Oct 91.38cash · Oct 13
    Hull Suite0.35cash · Oct 110.60cash · Oct 81.22cash · Oct 10
    ML Adaptive SuperTrend0.20cash · Oct 290.90cash · Oct 81.82cash · Oct 12
    Zero Lag Trend Signals0.44cash · Oct 160.54cash · Oct 80.82cash · Oct 8
    Zero-Lag MA Trend Levels0.61cash · Oct 151.03cash · Oct 92.17cash · Oct 11
    Golden Cross (50/200)0.33long · Sep 80.26long · Aug 31-0.02long · Sep 2
    200-Day Moving Average0.47cash · Nov 120.47cash · Nov 80.29cash · Nov 8
    MACD (12, 26, 9)0.48cash · Sep 290.32cash · Nov 80.98cash · Oct 1
    RSI 14 above 500.66cash · Nov 50.80cash · Nov 51.72cash · Oct 8
    Donchian Breakout (Turtle 20/10)0.64cash · Oct 80.32cash · Oct 71.23cash · Oct 7
    Parabolic SAR0.22cash · Oct 240.07cash · Nov 81.51cash · Oct 24
    Squeeze Momentum0.24cash · Oct 100.64cash · Oct 80.74cash · Oct 10
    Volumatic VIDYA0.28cash · Nov 20.59cash · Oct 290.40cash · Oct 29
    Volumatic Trend0.61cash · Oct 240.53cash · Oct 91.38cash · Oct 12

    MAR = annual return divided by the worst drawdown; higher is better. Full history since 2018, Solana since 2020. Green = beats holding. Click a cell for the backtest, charts and today's signal.

    Community MoneyLine by rafstar_kaczmarek, UT Bot Alerts by QuantNomad, Chandelier Exit and HalfTrend by everget, Range Filter by DonovanWall and guikroth, Gaussian Channel by DonovanWall, all open source on TradingView and credited to their authors; the strategy rules are our own implementation.