All articles

    Rule-Based Trend Signals for MSTR and TSLA: What a Daily Exit Rule Did in the Last Drawdowns

    A simple daily trend rule on Tesla and Strategy (MSTR): worst drop about a third of holding's since 2023, in cash on both today, and why most of the history is in-sample. Simulated backtest.

    StrategyaNovember 12, 20264 min read5 views
    Table of contents

    Tesla and Strategy (MSTR) are two of the most volatile large caps in the US market. Holding them has paid off over the long run, and it has also meant sitting through drops of 50% to 80%. This post looks at one question: what would a simple daily trend rule have done with them?

    The rule, in one paragraph

    One decision per stock per day. After the NYSE close, the rule checks whether the daily trend is up or down. Up: hold the stock. Down: move to cash. Orders fill at the next session open. No intraday moves, no price targets, no short selling. It does not try to call the bottom: after a drop it waits for the trend to turn, even if that means buying back higher than the low.

    The numbers

    Since Jan 2023Rule on TSLAHolding TSLARule on MSTRHolding MSTR
    Worst drop (max drawdown)17.5%53.8%25.4%82.6%
    Trades12–16–
    Last 12 monthsRule on TSLAHolding TSLARule on MSTRHolding MSTR
    Return−6.0%−11.1%+20.6%−47.1%
    Worst drop8.2%39.1%20.0%64.4%

    Simulated backtest with 0.1% commission per trade, not real performance and not investment advice. Window up to November 11, 2026.

    What stands out

    1. The drawdown is the real difference. On both stocks the rule's worst drop was about a third of holding's: 17.5% against 53.8% on Tesla, 25.4% against 82.6% on MSTR. Most people do not lose money because a stock is bad. They lose it because they sell at the bottom of a drop they could not sit through.

    2. It does not always win. Over the last 12 months the rule lost 6% on Tesla. It lost less than holding (−11.1%), but it still lost. In choppy markets a trend rule gets in and out for small losses. That is the price of being out when the big drops come.

    3. It is in cash right now on both. The Tesla rule left on November 5 after a flat 14-day trade (−0.25%). The MSTR rule left on October 13 after a 42-day trade (+18.8%). Neither will buy back until the daily trend turns up again.

    4. It will lag in a straight rally. When a stock only goes up, holding wins. You cannot beat a rocket by stepping off it. The edge shows up across a full cycle, mostly in the drops it skipped.

    5. Most of this history is in-sample. The settings of both rules were tuned on this same data: MSTR on 2023 to June 2026, Tesla on 2022 to September 2026. Since then, each rule has made exactly one new trade: +18.8% on MSTR and −0.25% on Tesla. That is far too little to prove anything, which is why both cards are public and update every day. The real test is the one running from here on.

    Why a rule and not a feeling

    MSTR fell more than 80% from its peak in this window, and Tesla more than 50%. At the bottom of each of those drops, the news was the worst it had been in months. A rule decides at the daily close, the same way every day, before the headlines get a vote.

    Both strategies have their own public card with today's position, every trade on the chart and results for each window (6 months, 1 year, 2 years, since 2023):

    At Strategya.pro each strategy is one card per asset: in or out, decided once a day. You can try them all free for 7 days, no credit card.

    All figures are simulated backtests, not real performance. Past results do not guarantee future results. None of this is investment advice.

    Share this article

    Strategya