All articles

    Do They Really Beat SuperTrend? 6 Indicators Tested on Bitcoin, Ether and Solana

    Six TradingView indicators that claim to beat SuperTrend, tested with the same rules on Bitcoin, Ether and Solana. They win 7 times out of 18. Simulated backtest.

    Strategya.proNovember 9, 20263 min read12 views
    Table of contents

    YouTube and TradingView are full of indicators that are "better than SuperTrend". Videos with millions of views say so, and so do scripts with tens of thousands of likes. We put the claim to a test.

    We took six of those indicators and ran them exactly like SuperTrend. Three come from a widely watched Short that presents them as better than SuperTrend: Pivot Point SuperTrend, AlphaTrend and Hull Suite. The other three are free and very popular, from two well-known indicator brands: ML Adaptive SuperTrend and Zero Lag Trend Signals by AlgoAlpha, and Zero-Lag MA Trend Levels by ChartPrime.

    Same rules for everyone

    • Long only: buy when the indicator says buy, go to cash when it says sell.
    • Daily candles, each author's default settings.
    • 0.1% commission on every buy and every sell.
    • From 2018 on Bitcoin and Ether, and from August 2020 on Solana, to November 8, 2026.
    • Every result was checked against TradingView's Strategy Tester.

    We compare them with MAR: annual return divided by the worst drawdown. A MAR of 1 means you made each year as much as you were down at the worst moment. Higher is better.

    The result: 7 out of 18

    MAR since 2018 of six indicators against SuperTrend on Bitcoin, Ether and Solana; only Zero-Lag MA Trend Levels beats it on all three
    MAR since 2018 (Solana since 2020). Simulated backtest, not real performance.
    IndicatorBitcoinEtherSolana
    SuperTrend (reference)0.420.851.95
    Zero-Lag MA Trend Levels0.611.032.19
    AlphaTrend0.830.791.39
    Pivot Point SuperTrend0.680.330.76
    Zero Lag Trend Signals0.440.550.83
    ML Adaptive SuperTrend0.200.901.83
    Hull Suite0.350.601.23
    Buy and hold0.260.130.71

    Bold when it beats SuperTrend. MAR since 2018 (Solana since 2020). Simulated backtest.

    1. On Bitcoin, four out of six win. SuperTrend is weak on Bitcoin (0.42), so the bar is low. AlphaTrend is the best of the six: 39% a year with a 47% max drawdown, against 22.6% and 53.6% for SuperTrend.

    2. On Ether and Solana, hardly any. Two win on Ether and one on Solana. All in all, the six "better than SuperTrend" indicators win 7 times out of 18.

    3. Only one wins on all three assets: Zero-Lag MA Trend Levels by ChartPrime. It is also the most consistent: second of 14 third-party indicators on Ether and on Solana.

    4. "Machine learning" is no guarantee. ML Adaptive SuperTrend is the second worst of the 14 third-party indicators we measured on Bitcoin, below simply holding the coin.

    5. One was left out because it cannot be measured. We wanted to include SuperTrend AI, one of the most popular "AI" indicators. Its Bitcoin result moves between +210% and +358% depending on how the same calculation is rounded. A number that depends on rounding cannot be published, so we did not publish it.

    What this means

    "Better than SuperTrend" is almost always shown with a hand-picked chart and a single asset. With the same rules on three assets, the claim holds less than half the time. Before you switch indicators, check how it did on more than one asset and over more than one window.

    Each of these indicators has its own page with the rule, the chart with every entry and exit, results by window (6 months, 1 year, 2 years, since 2023 and since 2018) and today's position.

    See them all: strategya.pro/benchmarks

    At Strategya.pro we do not start from a trendy indicator: each strategy comes from a rule tested per asset, with a daily card that says whether to be in or in cash. You can try them all free for 7 days, no credit card.

    All figures are simulated backtests, not real performance. Each indicator's logic belongs to its author (credited on each page); the strategy rules are our implementation with its default settings. Past results do not guarantee future results. None of this is investment advice.

    Share this article

    Strategya.pro